Battlestar Galactica: Season 4 (Spoilers)

[turbinea]

i enjoyed this ep as well, but i found one thing quite funny. romo and lee spent lot of time to find a new president because comander of the fleet wont accept zarek as a president. when they finaly found one, commander resigns and therefore renders all their effort pointless.

[Dr-Timelord]

Originally Posted by Freak

one final thing. Helo can still be a Cylon, !

This makes an interesting point making Hera a fully born natural cylon, the next step in evolution maybe?


The fleet is pretty much split down the middle, and who knows whats gonna happen when Roslin comes back and she finds Lee doing a better job than she is

[Flyingmonkey]

A little late but...

I found the writing on this episode surprisingly poor. I don't usually like to specifically point at one person and say "it's your fault" but I was so shocked at the way this seemed to be a series of unrelated conversation with a almost complete absence of plot all centered around story arc developments that seemed to have no justification given the events in the episodes I decided to do some looking. Turns out the writer credited with this one has produced some of the episodes, maybe with the exception of unfinished business, I found most lacking in the last 2 seasons (see imdb, though I don't know if it is an exhaustive list). For once rather than just saying this was good/this was bad I am going to say that this could have been good had it been completely re-written, case in point; when the lawyer guy goes to Adam on the hanger deck and Adam says "Mr. Lampkin, what are you doing here" it sounds like Olmos is almost choking out the words, there is no life, no reason just "hey, what would a person say if some guy walked up to him?" Olmos could have preformed better given the plot turns in the episode, but there was no script. this guy's episodes also seem to involve a lot of big ideas that are fairly vague, convoluted and irrelevant to the characters that present them or the episode plots they are in, it's hard to watch.

I don't know, maybe they should stop letting all the producers write episodes...

[mental|plate]

The fifth cylon is Mr. Lampkin.....why? because he has imaginary cat .

[Dr Lee]

one theory i've seen is that the final cylon is Doc Cottle

[Freak]

Originally Posted by turbinea

i enjoyed this ep as well, but i found one thing quite funny. romo and lee spent lot of time to find a new president because comander of the fleet wont accept zarek as a president. when they finaly found one, commander resigns and therefore renders all their effort pointless.

yes but they did not know Adama would step down, and by the time he did, Lee was already sowrn in.

Originally Posted by mental|plate

The fifth cylon is Mr. Lampkin.....why? because he has imaginary cat .

Yeah but Lee saw it too.

[mental|plate]

No he didnt, i mean he did saw it when he opened the bag with the dead cat in it and then he sad she was dead like for weeks, and just a few moments ago Mr. Lampkin was talking to it when he was writing lee adamas name. And it would be "logical" to bee him because he couldnt meet with the other four becouse he wasnt on galactica, but he did hear the music.....at least thats what i think

[Freak]

but he did see it at the trail.
Also when Mr. Lampkin droped the bag on a chair on Colonal One the cat did make a noise. which Lee did react to as he looked at the bag.

[Melak]

Hm. Cylon-Cylon pregnancy...does she know?

[Dr-Timelord]

I think it could be Romo Lampkin... it would make perfect sense in a way...he's a minor character who has had a significant impact on the colonial fleet due to Baltars trial